And a DVD review – ‘Layout Planning and Design’

Following my purchase of the BRM layout design special, I almost immediately came across a DVD review on the excellent ‘Basilica Fields’ blog.  (At least, it’s an excellent blog if you can cope with someone with a 30-year plan for a layout.  But the information on the old Great Eastern and other lines in East London is fascinating).  So I immediately bought the DVD, which is ‘Right Track 19: Layout Planning and Design’.  Having watched it, I was going to write my own full review here, but realised that the review at Basilica Fields was far better than I could manage.  So here’s an extract:

Many of us railway modellers are wedded to a scale and gauge, and this is the first sacred cow to be unceremoniously kicked over, and a compelling argument is put forward for choosing scale based on wants and needs from a new layout. Coupling choices are the next element to stand in the dock, and not just on the usual ‘play value versus scale appearance’ card we’re all so used to hearing, but instead based on how train length is affected by one type or the other, and how that impacts on our design. Thought provoking stuff.

With our comfortable world now turned upside down, we’re suddenly find ourselves within the habitat of the modeller; all so often our esoteric little hobby drags us away from family down into the shed at the bottom of the garden on a wet and windy night or up into the sauna-like humidity of a loft space in high summer. Not the always the best for harmonious household relations, and it needn’t be so. Based on a stylised representation of footfall though the house, we’re shown where hitherto unconventional sites for a ‘shelfie’ may in fact prove to be ideal and leave us feeling a little less like Johnny-no-mates.

On to the nitty-gritty; what do we want from a layout? Actually, what do we need might be the better question, and after writing out a checklist we’re building a quick mock-up from card and foam to see if all these elements of desire and necessity actually work together. Our perception of perspective, layout width and the backscene are briefly challenged – a foreshadow of things to come later in the programme.

Read the full review here and get a flavour of the DVD below.

The reviewer concludes:

On being sent my gratis reviewer’s copy, I was told to tell it as it is; good or bad – don’t pull your punches. Despite not receiving my promised reviewer’s fee of a bacon sandwich (you owe me in sauce Mistah PMP), I thoroughly recommend this DVD to newcomers of the hobby and grizzled old hands alike.

I agree completely, even having paid for a copy, with no exchange of bacon products at any time.  Again, I recommend this for anyone who like layout planning, and watching it may result in a few plans getting constructed.  Buy it from Activity Media, here.

 

 

Posted in Hints and tips, Inspiration, Layout design, The trade | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

And the rest – Tolworth #2

Having recovered from Fencehouses, here are a few more photos from Tolworth Showtrain – a few more layouts that caught my eye.

First, ‘Cornwallis Yard’, a GWR layout with a little SR thrown in.  With my south London upbringing, and my interest in the Great Eastern I think the natural place for a railway is on top of a brick (or concrete) viaduct.  If it’s a goods yard on top of the viaduct, so much the better!  Here I liked the high and low-level yards, the multiple bridges hiding the exit from the layout to the left, and the nicely modelled buildings.

c-1 c-2

Whilst talking about trains on viaducts, ‘Blackfriars Bridge’ is a work in progress, modelling that London terminus around 1900 (or perhaps a little before).  A peek over the wall into the fiddle yard revealed some very interesting early rolling stock.

P1040689 P1040688 P1040687

ESNG members of a certain vintage will remember Dave Bran’s N-mod module of Cromford, on the Cromford and High Peak mineral line.  There was a tidy ‘N’ gauge version of the same prototype on display.

P1040662

I’ll have to include Maloja for the ESNG Swiss fans.  A few years back, there would be some novelty to a Swiss railway (just as there would be for a Japanese one, and other less well known prototypes.)  But as our knowledge of the more unusual prototypes improves, you can’t just get away with novelty at a show – and the standard of modelling seems to get better and better (even on the Thomas and friends layout….)

P1040686 P1040685 P1040684

And finally, the American room had a nice spread of USA modelling – from ‘Z’ to ‘HO’, standard and narrow gauge, but the lighting was appalling!

u-1 u-2 u-3 u-4 u-5

Posted in Inspiration, Layout design, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Fabulous Fencehouses – Tolworth #1

Despite the terrible traffic – everyone was on the roads this morning – I got to Tolworth Showtrain today.  It was of its usual high standard and there were a number of layouts that provided a certain amount of inspiration.  My only criticism of the show was that some parts of the halls were poorly lit – it was difficult to see some layouts at their best, and my photos are mostly of those with their own lighting.

As ever, there was also plenty of trade to tempt the unwary.  And I did very well and didn’t buy anything at all….

Of course, star of the show was the enormous 2mm finescale ‘Fenhouses, described on one advert as:

This exquisite 2mm Finescale model depicts 1¼ scale miles of railway in County Durham, including a tall viaduct. The layout is some 40 feet long and this will be the first time it has been shown in Southern England.

My photographs of the layout and a few comments are appended below.  I’ll do a second post with a few other layouts that impressed me.  The first thing that strikes you with Fencehouses is the sheer size of 40 foot of finescale 2mm.  Below are the yard sidings and a general view of the station itself.

f-1 f-2

Then you look a little closer, and realise just how good and detailed the modelling is.  Below are the level crossing, the colliery buildings, and the distinctive North Eastern Railway over track signal cabin.  Whilst I was there, most trains running were of British Railways green diesel vintage.  They can take the layout back into steam days, but for a two day exhibition, a lot of the donkey work was being done by Farish diesels converted to finescale standards.

f-3 f-4 f-5 f-6

Two miles north of Fence Houses is Victoria viaduct, some 800 feet long and 135 feet high. Built between 1836-1838, it is today a listed structure.  The model captures the pure bulk of the thing, and it is an ideal spot for a little trainspotting, as long passenger and coal trains trundle across it at realistic scale speeds (no bullet trains here!)

f-7 f-8 f-9

And as for staging – how about this?  Note the colour lights over the loops to aid the operators, and a ‘Deltic’ about to appear onto the public side of the layout.

f-10

In the end, what makes this layout special is the finescale track.  It’s difficult to see that the complex pointwork below is 2mm scale (especially when the trees and fences are also so very well modelled).  Having said that, it’s not so much the narrow clearances at point blades and frog that are noticeable, rather it’s the scale rail section.  With code 40 ‘N’ gauge track now available commercially, and most modern stock will run on it OK, it would be possible to get close to this in ‘N’ gauge.

f-11

Posted in Inspiration, Layout design, Out and about | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

ESNG meeting – 6 November 2014

A good turnout of a dozen members last night.  Not a lot to report, and I slipped off home early, partly since it was Maxine’s birthday, and partly since I was tired, having spent a lot of time fitting new fluorescent units to the church hall.

Predictably, John and Paul were test running some of their spoils from Eurospoor.  Paul also had a long Japanese container train on the go, with an interesting variety of wagons and containers.  Allan’s Swiss passenger train seemed to want to play slip coaches.  Martin and Neil were racing HST125’s on parallel tracks.  Neil had done a nice job weathering some ScotRail Mk3 coaches, and repainting the roofs to match some of his blue and grey stock.

With just two weeks before Stuttgart, it was good to see that the layout modules were running OK on their last outing before the show.  There was a little trouble with a couple of points, but that may have been incompetence as much as electronics.  Usually, it’s about now that things start to fail….

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Where I’ll be on Saturday

Tolworth Showtrain – the annual exhibition of the Hampton Court Model Railway is one exhibition I try to get to every year.  It’s of a high standard and has an ‘American room’ devoted to USA layouts and traders.

This year, on 8-9 November, there is an added reason to go – 2mm fine scale modelling on the grand scale.  The UK Model Shops site says that:

2mm Finescale Layout to make London Debut

The star of Tolworth Showtrain 2014 will be Fencehouses, a 2mm Finescale layout depicting some 1¼ miles of railway in County Durham which will be making it’s London and Southeast debut. A feature of this layout is the Victoria Viaduct which is some 3 feet high. The show will have 25 layouts along with 27 traders, together with various Society stands. There will be the usual American themed section. Easy parking and bus link from Surbiton Station. Free Accompanied Child offer on Sunday. For further details go to the Exhibition Calendar or the Tolworth Showtrain website.

Should be excellent, as these photos suggest, and worth catching a northern layout rarely seen in the south-east.

Posted in Inspiration, Layout design, Out and about | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Book review – ‘The BRM Guide to Trackplans & Layout Design

Browsing in WH Smiths (as one does) today, I came across a new British Railway Modelling publication, their ‘Guide to Trackplans & Layout Design’.  I’m a sucker for any book of track plans, so I quickly parted with my £5.99 (and got a 20% off voucher for next month and some MacDonald’s coupons as an extra), and took it home to read.

post-14186-0-21815900-1409667772

On the RMweb site, the ‘blurb’ says:

This 132-page ‘Guide to Trackplans & Layout Design’ is the ultimate tool for railway modellers looking to build a model railway layout of any size!

It includes more than 55 inspirational layout trackplans in a variety of gauges including N, OO and O. The layout plans are split into three categories:

  1. Micro and small layout plans
  2. Medium layout plans
  3. Plans for large layouts

Each layout plan includes a description of the layout featured, factfile and a list of reasons for and against this particular plan. You can also expect stunning layout photography from the likes of Andy York, Tony Wright and Paul Bason!

You’ll also find a mix of additional articles to aid your layout planning. These articles include:

  • What makes a great trackplan
  • Finding a home for your layout
  • Scales and gauges
  • Track for the OO modeller
  • Layout planning tips, stats and dimensions
  • Layout planning techniques

Have to say, it does exactly what it says on the can.  There are some very basic techniques and ideas described to start with, but I never mind being reminded of the basics of our hobby.  It is also very good to have all these ideas put into a single document for later browsing.

Have looked at these pages, there are some excellent track plans to inspire the reader.  I only knew some of the layouts, not being a regular reader of BRM, so this was a bonus.  It was good to see the historic ‘Borchester’ layout of Frank Dyer included.  I remember seeing this layout at Central Hall back in the 1960’s and 1970’s and it was so far ahead of it’s time.  Yes, there were some Hornby locomotives, but everything ran to a timetable, for a purpose, and the layout was operated and was very realistic.  Another favourite included is Trevor Nunn’s ‘West Lynn’ in ‘S’ scale.  I’ve seen this at several exhibitions, and it never fails to impress (and I do like the old Great Eastern railway).  The plan from the book is shown below.

2_130640_310000000

All in all this little publication is a good read, not expensive, and thoroughly recommended.

Posted in Hints and tips, Inspiration, Layout design, The trade | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Eurospoor 2014 (4) – And finally…. the USA

My last set of Eurospoor photographs show models of the USA.  Everyone seems to model US outline, and there were some excellent models on display.  ‘City Limits’ would appear to be part of a larger modular layout.  The industrial decay and grime was well captured without being overstated and reduced to caricature.  I sort of wished there was some of the main line exhibited, with the heavy traction in evidence but unable to run.

DSCF1220 DSCF1169 DSCF1165

Flemmingsburg was a fine ‘O’ and ‘On3’ layout.  American models in O-gauge have a real bulk about them and they have momentum like the real thing.  Lots of fine models here.

DSCF1166 DSCF1168 DSCF1197 DSCF1198 DSCF1199

Now, that’s what I call a fiddle yard…..

DSCF1196

And finally, finally, finally, another O gauge narrow gauge layout.  Very much a work in progress.

DSCF1161

For a more detailed look at Eurospoor, have a read of that wonderfully titled blog ‘Motorised Dandruff’ – nominally about NZ120 modelling – but with three blog posts here, here and here, with far more words and pictures than my paltry efforts!

Posted in ESNG, Inspiration, Out and about, The trade | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Eurospoor 2014 (3) – UK visitors

A pleasant surprise at Eurospoor was the visiting UK based layouts.  I had seen recently seen two of these at UK shows, but it was good to see them flying the flag for UK layouts.  Firstly ‘Warren Lane’.  You’d think that a layout that just shuffled container wagons around would be pretty boring.  But not when there is a working travelling crane loading and unloading the container wagons.  And when one looks at the trains more closely, there are so many different types of wagon and indeed container in use.

DSCF1183 DSCF1184 DSCF1186 DSCF1185

I’d also seen ‘Kayreuth’ in recent weeks.  This complex N-gauge German layout is in some ways more ‘European’ than some of the European layouts on display.  Lots of tracks and lots of trains on display – I had to remind myself that we had just travelled on a similar prototype from Schipol to Ultrech.

DSCF1192 DSCF1191

Last of the UK contingent was Rhydwyn, an O-gauge model of a steel mill, with an explanation of the manufacturing processes being carried out.

DSCF1194

Finally today, here are two photos of one of my favourite layouts from the show.  Not from the UK, or indeed UK prototype, but Helenensiel has all the features of a sleepy UK branch line terminus – but I’ve never seen such a model in Z-gauge before.  It’s difficult to tell that it’s ‘Z’ and it ran perfectly.

DSCF1193 DSCF1163

Posted in ESNG, Inspiration, Out and about, The trade | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Eurospoor 2014 (2) – European models

Today I’ll post some shots of the best European modelling on display.  We start with Gletsch, a HO-m model of the Swiss metre gauge.  There seemed to be little compression of the station area, and the narrow gauge was allowed to sprawl though the landscape.  Most impressive were the rack sections and steep gradients that meant the layout started near head height, the station was normal baseboard level, then the track dropped down near to the floor.  One impressive piece of modelling was the broken water of the mountain torrent parallel to the lower rack section.  I hope this comes out in the photos below.

DSCF1158 DSCF1157 DSCF1223 DSCF1224

Next we move to ‘Braggels Baenke’ (reminds me of that old kid’s show, ‘Fraggles Rock).  This is a Dutch steam / early diesel terminus with some delightful modelling.  Modellers in the Netherlands seem to have closest to the UK ‘ethos’ for scale modelling.  I enjoyed the slow shunting movements, the nicely understated scenery, some delightful prototypes, and the working lifting bridge over the canal.

DSCF1181 DSCF1182 DSCF1180 DSCF1179

Finally, some O-gauge narrow gauge modelling.  A modular layout with lots of very good structure modelling and even a working rope incline.

DSCF1206 DSCF1205 DSCF1204

Next time, some UK visitors!

 

 

Posted in ESNG, Inspiration, Out and about, The trade | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Eurospoor 2014 (1) – A long day

Yesterday’s trip to Eurospoor has come and gone.  It was an excellent, but very, very, long day.  It’ll take several blogs to do justice to it all.  In summary….

  • 0609: On Earlswood station to catch the first train of the day, three stops to Gatwick.
  • 0805: Breakfast and desperately needed coffee in Starbucks at Gatwick (where’s a MacDonald’s when you need one).  Met John and Paul at the gate, and took off by EasyJet to Amsterdam Schipol.
  • 10:15: Arrive Schipol and walk straight from airport onto the station concourse.  Like Gatwick but 19 platforms not 7 (I’m reliably informed that Schipol is the main junction in the Netherlands, where four lines meet).
  • 10:45:  Having worked out the self-service ticket machine, we only have a three minutes wait for a train to Utrecht.  It’s a yellow and blue NS double deck EMU.  We take the top deck and watch the world go by.  It’s a fast and quiet ride, but I am relieved that it’s not perfect, as there is graffiti sprayed in the entrance lobby.  We pass through a little bit of countryside, but mainly the outer suburbs of Amsterdam.
  • 11:30: It’s a bit of a walk in the rain from Utrecht station to the exhibition hall, but we are soon inside and planning the day.  John and Paul opt to go shopping first (surprise, surprise), but I first walk around both halls (one mainly trade, one mainly layouts).  Looking at the trade was very interesting, and I was (as always) tempted to buy a Flying Hamburger (German DMU) and also buy some Dutch stock, but resisted.  I’ll describe the layouts in more detail later.
  • 17:00:  Footsore and (in two cases) considerably poorer, we leave the show to walk to ‘Chez Willie’s’, John and Paul’s recommended eating house.
  • 17:30: Oh dear, Willie is no longer there.  Chez Willie’s has become a tapas bar.  Still, we eat there anyway and have a tasty, if a little pricey meal.
  • 20:00:  Having taken the train back to Schipol, we experience the usual EasyJet end-of-day knock on delay, and our 21:20 flight leaves at 22:00 or so.
  • 22:00:  A 45 quick minute flight back from Gatwick, and I miss the last train that stops at Earlswood by 10 minutes.  Thank you EasyJet.  So I take a train to the next station, Redhill, and an SOS to Maxine means that transport home is awaiting.
  • 23:00: Arrive home to be greeted by the budgie.
  • 23:15: BED.

So to the layouts.  I’ll probably take three or four posts with the photos.  Today, just a few giving a flavour of what was going on.  Then two or three more with some of the best layouts.  Apologies for a few of the photos.  I had to use my old camera, and I think the focussing is going a little strange…. So here we are, in the main hall.  Big by most UK standards.

DSCF1200 Of the layouts, there were a number of modular set ups.  Some were ‘boxed’ scenes linked together, and others more generic HO or Marklin HO layouts.  There was often some very good modelling tucked away in these scenes. DSCF1159 DSCF1203 DSCF1217 There was some very good narrow gauge modelling on display.

DSCF1171 And some unusual scenes.  Here we have plenty of Z-gauge snow and a touch of broad gauge.

DSCF1176 DSCF1212 A interesting stand was the ‘A4 challenge’, a series of A4 dioramas, all having some excellent modelling.

DSCF1189 DSCF1188 DSCF1187

Next time, I’ll have a more detailed look at some of the very good layouts on display. And how does it compare with the Stuttgart show?  For the shopper, Eurospoor must be better, with a whole hall of new and second-hand shops (though Honest John had to hunt for the bargains, as prices were generally high).  Stuttgart does seem to have more exhibits from the major manufacturers and more ‘small parts’ stands from specialist suppliers.  The layouts were probably comparable in number and standard, though Eurospoor has more and a much wider variety.  (Stuttgart being, of course, dominated by the N-club modular monstrosity).  Perhaps where Stuttgart does win out is that it is also a social event for the N-club meet.  And in fairness, both are well worth a visit.

Posted in ESNG, Inspiration, Out and about, The trade | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment