Stuttgart 2016 #2 – ESNG at play

The ESNG contribution looked, in part, much as a normal club night, with a procession of trains of varying parentage taking to the tracks.  The Farish Blue Pullman deserves a mention as it ran faultlessly for all four days.

s2_0

‘ERIC’ went Network Southeast for the show, giving Sean an opportunity to show off all his models.  The stripy blue livery was one of the better on to grace UK rails in recent years, although it was possibly subliminal advertisement for a well known brand of toothpaste.  We cheated a bit and split up the multiple units to fill two of the roundhouse tracks….

s2_2

s2_3

s2_4

After the 4-track N-mod sections, the main line dropped to N-club 2-track modules.  Martin’s model of Ford station is a nicely compressed model of a real location on the south coast, and the Gaugemaster shop can be seen in the background.  Last year, we found that the dummy outside 3rd rail was set a little high and tended to lift locomotives off the track.  That was solved, but this year we found a few dips in the trackwork that need attention.

s2_5

The modular setup was in the form of a U, with 4-track N-mod along one side, 2-track N-club along the end, and then 2-track N-club fronting the Konigshaven layout along the other leg of the U.  Konigshaven exhibited at Stuttgart 10 years ago, and the owners took the opportunity for a 10th anniversary return.  All ran well for all four days, a complement to the builders of what is now a 20-year old layout.  The only disaster was a train of wagons that found their way to the floor.  Fortunately most survived, and the others can be renovated with new bogies.

s2_6

s2_7

Thursday night was, as usual, lock-in party night at the show venue, with each club bringing national food (and drink).  Here’s the ESNG contribution with items such as clotted crème scones, a range of British cheeses, and delicacies such as Walkers Crisps, mince pies and Twiglets.

s2_8

And of course the ever popular barrel of Sussex bitter.  The club members are shown in characteristic poses (sorry about the fade in the photos – my phone couldn’t cope with such photogenic objects….)

s2_9

s2_10

s2_11

s2_12

Back at the show, one stand had a series of amazing dioramas, including this one of the Tour de France.  I just don’t know how many figures were used in this wonderful model….

s2_13

s2_14

s2_15

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Stuttgart 2016 #1 – Stuttgart itself

Last week, ESNG completed its annual pilgrimage to the Stuttgart N-Club meet and show.  I went for the full four days this year, for the first time.  My impressions of the whole thing – four days is great fun, but not twice as good as two days (work that one out if you can) – and that the full show is exhausting.  I did very little on Monday, the day after I got back.  A model railway show doesn’t seem hard work, but you’re always active, operating and just putting things back on the track.

We also had plenty of discussions as to ESNG’s direction, but more of that another time.

Of course, one benefit of spending four days in Stuttgart was the chance to take a train down town, and see the town centre for the first time in seven years!  So we’ll start this year’s review with a few photographs of the real thing.  The views from the observation platform on the top of  the station tower are excellent – despite the rain.

s1_1

The station roof is in the foreground, and the temporary platform access is to the right.

s1_2

All this station area shown here, leading off to the carriage and loco yards in the far centre distance are being abandoned and redeveloped.  Trains will still run through this location though.  The station is being rebuilt underground and at 90 degrees to the existing station, so that through trains will not have to reverse when they stop at Stuttgart.  The magnitude of the project is gigantic, and will free up great areas for development and park land through the crowded river valley.  Perhaps we should have done something similar at London Bridge?  But the planning enquiries would have gone on for ever…..

s1_3

In the Stuttgart show there was part of a model of the Stuttgart station as it was 20 years ago.  The owner had been building the layout for 30 years or so, and had recently died, leaving his layout to the Stuttgart club.  They managed to get part of the layout out of its room into the Messe for its first public showing ever.

s1_4

All the good sidings and sheds in the background below have already been redeveloped – look at the trainspotter’s photographs that follow.

s1_5

s1_6

Meanwhile, back in the station, Allan, Derek and I went and stood on the end of the platform to watch the trains.  Plenty of movement to see, though being a Saturday, it wasn’t worth a trip to another station to look for goods.

These first two photos, of the same scene, are interesting in how identical reds have come out differently in photographs taken within seconds of each other.

s1_7

s1_8

Push-pull sets waiting to depart.  Note the redevelopment in the background….

s1_9

A former East German loco and double-deck stock.  Again, interesting to see how the red loco has faded in colour…..

s1_10

s1_11

The station control centre….

s1_12

Black is the new red…..

s1_13

An ICE3 enters the platform….

s1_14

And an view of the link between units.  Just like Kato…..

s1_15

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Layout design – redux – different voices – simple layout, complex operation

The third post, a long way behind the traction ones, is about small, switching layouts.


Another interesting voice in the layout design world is Lance Mindheim, who most originally posts at http://www.lancemindheim.com/.

GMR47pic

He has built a number of very interesting layouts.  The first was a 20×20 foot N gauge layout of the Chicago, Indianapolis and Louisville or as it’s usually known, the Monon in Indiana in 1955.

He then moved to modelling modern-day Miami in HO.  The small East Rail was a 10×10 foot L-shaped switching layout.  Simple, but lots of operation.

ZopsSmall images

The room-sized Downtown Spur occupies the full 20×20 foot of the railway room.  It is wonderful modelling, and a couple of photographs in a recent Model Railroader article really could have been the real thing.

Ant300 CourtyardSouthThumb

So, what are the design points we can learn from Lance’s brilliant modelling?

  1. The ordinary makes a good model.  It’s better to model a realistic square concrete box of a warehouse, than some fancy, and unrealistic, building.
  2. Switching takes time.  There’s the time at each road crossing.  There’s the flares to light at ungated crossings.  There’s the time to uncouple or couple the wagons.  There’s the time taken to walk from one end of the train to the other.  There’s the time taken to unlock points and relock them after switching.  It all adds up to a slow procedure if its done realistically.
  3. One siding can act as three or four, if there are a number of different industries, or different doors on a single building, that need cars spotted in front of them.

Lance’s blog includes a number of deceptively simple switching layouts.  But if operated as the prototype, even a couple of sidings can offer an hour or two’s instant entertainment.

(All pictures, from Lance Mindheim’s website)


Lance Mindheim continues to build small switching layouts.  His latest is an HO model of the Los Angeles Junction Railway.  Read about it here.  It’s another L-shaped plan, and as with his earlier work perfectly captures the run down modern freight branch.  Only two points, but plenty of operation.

Lance describes the ethos of his plan…..

As we zero in our target of planning a layout that meets our personal interests, consideration needs to be given to that subtle component called time.  Time, in all its aspects, plays a dominant role in whether we are blissfully content or miss the mark.

  1. How much time do I have to spend on the layout?
    Which activities do I want to be engaged in during that available time?
  2. How long do I want an operating session to last?
  3. Do I want to spend my available time covering a small area with high levels of detail or larger areas with a more basic/representative detail level?
  4. How long will I live in my present home?

So, to answer everybody’s questions, no the LAJ layout isn’t a test bed but rather the result of my answers to the above questions.  I want a highly detailed urban layout.   I want to fulfill my lifelong interest in finally modeling at least a portion of the LAJ.  I want a design that can sustain thirty to forty-five-minute op. sessions (but really doesn’t need to sustain anything longer). My available hobby time isn’t what it used to be and I need to factor that in if I’d like the layout to be mostly complete in the next eighteen months.   When I pick up my throttle I want to feel transported to the dry heat of LA and run under the palms and past iconic art deco structures.  That’s what I’m up to.

z1

And would you believe this is a model?

z2

(Photo, Lance Mindheim website)

Posted in Inspiration, Jon's layout ramblings, Layout design | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Off my trolley – redux – interurban branchlines – 1

This post has always been popular, too….


A good, if rather conventional, place to start with interurban layouts, is the conventional branch line.  Some electric railroads were no more than a branch line in total.  Others, like the Pacific Electric, had twigs off the branches off the trunk.  An interurban branchline has all the merits of a conventional one – small space, little stock needed, and what one builds can be built to a good standard.

I think it’s going to take several posts to explore just a few of the options!

Let’s start with a true branch line layout.  6 foot long in HO and short trains of two or three cars, and the occasional preserved interurban.  This is Andy Gautrey’s Wiley City on the Yakima Valley.  This little layout has a simple track plan, and some well observed modelling.

Wiley City 10 KONICA MINOLTA DIGITAL CAMERA

You can read all about this lovely little layout, with plenty of photos, on RMweb.

Let’s contrast this with an example from the prototype.  When the Pacific Electric Railway (or at least its predecessor) came to the San Fernando valley, there was nothing but fields of grain.  If you go there now, there is nothing but sprawling suburbs.  The interurban opened up this part of the Los Angeles region.  The freeways did the rest of the damage.

At the very end of the Pacific Electric empire lay San Fernando itself.  Even after the passenger service from downtown had been abandoned, the ‘Orphan Spur’ – an isolated mile or two of track that served a few profitable citrus packing houses.  A single locomotive lived on the spur and dealt with all switching.  This little line would make a good model, especially if the passenger service from downtown was kept going into the post-war period.  The map below comes from Bruce Petty’s excellent ‘Los Angeles River Railroads’ site, as does his interpretation of this line.

pesfsp_pe_layout

For more, see his San Fernando page .

Mission_San_Fernando_Postcard,_circa_1900

One attraction of this line is a chance to model the San Fernando Mission.  The postcard below is its 1900’s form.  It was extended a lot in later years, but the simple building shown here would be the right sort of size for a model railroad.  A little modeller’s licence would place it next to the tracks rather than a road away.

10545
If you are really interested in this line, I can recommend this book.  It’s full of delightful pictures and lots of information on the freight and interurbans and also plenty of social history of the area.  However, you will probably have to get it from the USA, as even Amazon don’t seem to stock it here in the UK.

 

 


Wiley City has been a regular on the exhibition circuit, and I was delighted to see it ‘in the flesh’.  Here are some YouTube video of it in action (the oldest a frightening 5 years old)….

And one of the real thing – at least the centenary celebrations…..

And the San Fernando branch is still a possible future layout for yours truly.  If only someone would produce 3D printed Pacific Electric cars.

Posted in Layout design, Traction | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Off my trolley – redux – streetcars and trolley layouts

As I’m in Stuttgart this week, I thought I’d repost the three most popular posts since I started blogging three or more years ago.  I’ve updated them a little, too.  One difference I note from starting blogging – I cut picture size to save storage space; now I just don’t bother!


Again we need a cultural translation here: trolley = streetcar = tram.  Streetcars tended to be smaller that the big interurbans running between towns.  But you could find an interurban winding its way through the city traffic on its way to the city terminal.

What is missing from a trolley layout is extensive freight operations.  Freight cars might be seen on inner city tracks, but this was not common.  What you might see is a freight motor (in the UK think the Southern Region Motor Luggage Van) moving small quantities of freight around.  But the passenger service is intense, although it will consist of a single coach, or perhaps two.  (Having said all this, there will be exceptions to the rule somewhere – please don’t tell me I’m completely wrong).

So a trolley layout has real potential for a tight space.  Short trains, very sharp curves, lots of urban scenery to model.  There is a lot going for such a layout, if you can face the idea of a layout with little freight and few of the conventional railway buildings.

To illustrate the potential, here are two links to excellent layouts.  The first is Fred Miller’s HO scale trolley model site (http://www.fnbcreations.net/tractionfan/).  Here are a couple of photos from the site, showing the high detail and concentrated modelling.  If you wonder about the curves, they are 6 ¼” radius representing a prototype 45 ft radius – in HO scale.  Even TOMIX Japanese tram track has a smallest radius of 4″!

gc003 gc004

I was somewhat annoyed to find that the entire layout now lives in Charlotte’s Trolley museum.  We tried to visit the museum when visiting Charlotte –  but it was closed.  And that was before I discovered the layout was there.

The second layout is again HO and from Australia.  Victoria Street, living at http://glennofootscray.blogspot.com.au/ describes itself as:

“A small model tramway layout loosely based on the Melbourne Metropolitan Tramway Board (MMTB).  Originally set up as a test track, like all layouts evolved into some thing more, with a slight west suburban slant towards its location.

The modules are only 57cm long by 19cm deep, so far there are four complete modules (railway station and racecourse, the original modules), another module is the undecorated fiddle yard (city) and two recent modules are (the railway gates and the bend, Epsom Rd).  Victoria St can run as an end of line tramway, a heritage/regional (SEC) line, and a shuttle passenger service with short shunting at the station to service extra punters for the racecourse to a time table run to a 3:1 fast clock.”

Again note the size of the modules – again remember these are HO scale.  Below are photos from the site, showing the compact size.

7989917027_5fc61acab6_o   5818995435_a63f168b79_o

1458711_10152066299369664_362333344_nAnd finally, this photo does suggest that this blogger has visited the layout – unfortunately not, must be some relation.


Updating the above…..  Fred Miller’s modules have moved museum in North Carolina, and the site has a couple of tantalising shots of his new home layout – I’d like to see more of this, as it looks to be of the same quality as ‘Gotham’.

Victoria Street has grown by several modules and is no longer a scenic test track, but a full tramways layout.  Over the past couple of years, there have been accounts of exhibiting the layout and a move to DCC – ideal for trams, where like buses nowadays you could wait for ever then three would come along together.  The website has regular updates, and I’ve culled a couple of recent photos (at a reasonable size) to show progress.

t1

t2

t3

Posted in Inspiration, Jon's layout ramblings, Layout design, Traction | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

ESNG PlayDay – 13 November 2016

Another excellent afternoon playing trains.  Even more paying members that the last PlayDay – 15 – plus 3 visitors.  The treasurer was there to collect the money, too!  Miles was in attendance, as evidenced by this partly demolished cake…..

wp_20161113_15_09_09_pro

Graham and Dave were helping eat it…..

wp_20161113_15_09_28_pro

Paul is setting up yet another bullet train…..

wp_20161113_15_12_20_pro

To add to those already up and running…..

wp_20161113_15_12_50_pro

John was testing this interesting early Swiss electric, whilst Simon ran a 22 car Santa Fe passenger train….

wp_20161113_15_10_02_pro

Less said about this collection the better…..

wp_20161113_16_33_12_pro

Sean brought his layout along, and there has been some progress in the scenery and ballast around the track….

wp_20161113_15_09_41_pro

I brought my module along ready to go to Stuttgart….

wp_20161113_15_20_46_pro

At the end of the afternoon we left a cache of modules, trains and other equipment to load into the van on Monday for the trip to Stuttgart.  And eight of us then retired for curry!

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Tolworth 2016

A year has slipped past, and once again I scrounged a lift off Derek Atfield to pay a visit to the Tolworth Showtrain exhibition.  And once again I nearly didn’t go – it was a foul wet morning – and I’m in Stuttgart this week – but it was worth the trip.  Just a few photos of the many layouts follow, with the things that caught my eye.

Trezeath is a pleasant model of the Southern Region in Cornwall.  A seaside terminal station allowing large Bullied Pacifics to make an appearance on some part of the ‘Atlantic Coast Express’.

wp_20161112_10_00_56_pro

Vogan Terminal features this rather fine refinery.  Derek and I did spot one or two pipes that weren’t connected, but the overall impression is most realistic.  Not sure what it produces though…..  oil?  gin?  marmite?

wp_20161112_10_01_50_pro

My favourite in the show, Castlederg, County Tyrone is a model of a real Irish 3′ narrow gauge terminus in OON3.  A delightful model of a delightful prototype.  One day I’ll build my Irish narrow gauge layout…..

wp_20161112_10_03_02_pro

wp_20161112_10_03_39_pro

wp_20161112_10_05_24_pro

A good line-up of Southern locomotives from the Guildford ‘O’ gauge group….

wp_20161112_10_12_06_pro

Another favourite.  Obbekaer is an HO layout of a through station set in Denmark in steam days.  A very simple, three point, track plan, but very good modelling throughout.  The sort of coach thing in the foreground is a railcar/shunting tractor.

wp_20161112_10_18_00_pro

wp_20161112_10_18_08_pro

wp_20161112_10_19_35_pro

One of the ‘N’ gauge viaducts on Dentdale….

wp_20161112_10_31_34_pro

Gouttieres is a diorama with one of those delightful French railcars shuttling back-and-forth.  Nil points, but plenty to look at in the scenery.

wp_20161112_10_33_26_pro

The usual American room had some good layouts, including a large ‘N’ gauge modular layout.  However, it looked a bit empty without SPV selling their books, and LSWR models (Penguin has finally retired.)

wp_20161112_10_43_02_pro

wp_20161112_10_45_52_pro

And to finish, a variation on the ‘Thomas, R.I.P.’ theme…..

wp_20161112_10_04_21_pro

Posted in Exhibitions, Inspiration, Layout design, Out and about | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Jon’s modules – a new module – the Club House

You will recall a while back, I posted Allan’s holiday snap of an interesting building in Switzerland made out of old containers…..

imag0594

And how I had bought a bag of cheap containers at TINGS…..

wp_20161004_13_25_57_pro

Well, I found the site of the building on Google Earth, that gave some clues as to size and the layout of the sides not shown in Allan’s photograph…..

containers

So, I’m please to present a slight flight of whimsy, a model of East Surrey N Gauge’s new headquarters.  If only, they all said.  It took a few evenings to build, and the number of containers was reduced to match the number I had bought.

wp_20161110_20_50_06_pro

The building is located in it’s own grounds next to a main line for a little trainspotting.  And parked in the grounds is an ex-SCNF Cinema Coach, used for showing railway films (and perhaps the occasional French art cinema production when no-one is looking.)

wp_20161110_20_50_19_pro

wp_20161110_20_49_58_pro

A disused signal box is located by the level crossing – perhaps a future preservation project.

wp_20161110_20_50_29_pro

Of course, the new ESNG headquarters must have a branch of the Ruchita curry house on site to keep the members fed and watered.  It was a preserved Red Star Parcels building (courtesy of Graham Farish), but it has been taken over for more important things.

wp_20161110_20_51_02_pro

I’m quite pleased how this has all come together, in about a month or so.  There is more detailing to complete – I need to add people and vehicles to give it a bit of life, and crash barriers are a must for the road bridge.  I bought some plastic ones from a well known supplier, but they were unbelievably fragile.  I may need to use 4mm bullhead rail soldered to pins to give a more robust structure.  Still, this is good enough for Stuttgart next week, and I can add the rest of the detail before the ESNG show next April.

wp_20161110_20_51_17_pro

And last job was to build a ply cover to store the module and hopefully get it to Stuttgart in one piece!

wp_20161110_20_51_26_pro

This has been a most enjoyable little project – not least in that it hasn’t been too serious!  No prototype, no concerns about operation, just good clean fun!!

Posted in Jon's layout ramblings, Layout design, N Club International | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Odd modelling idea #96

I don’t think I’ve done this one before!  From the Daily Telegraph and CNN (amongst others.)

Main road swallowed up as huge sinkhole collapses in centre of Japanese city

Residents of a major Japanese city woke up to a main road being swallowed up on Monday.  A large sinkhole opened up around dawn in the centre of Fukuoka, on Japan’s southern Kyushu island, with all five lanes of a street caving in.

Located at the intersection of a busy road near a train station, the collapse, which occurred just after 5am, caused no casualties but resulted in evacuations, traffic disruption, gas leaks and electricity blackouts, according to Kyodo News.  Residents reported that electricity suddenly cut in nearby buildings before they heard a loud noise as the road began to cave in on itself shortly before sunrise.

This has some modelling potential.  Apart from some interesting cameos, like cars hanging over the edge, and lots of emergency services, there is also the opportunity to model some underground features, like drains, cables and so on.

s1 s2 s3

Reminds me of the old joke – “A sink hole has appeared in Redhill Station Road.  Police are looking into it.”  Sorry…..

Posted in Hints and tips, Inspiration, Out and about, Weird and wonderful | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

One for election day…..

As America goes to the polls, with a choice ‘from the sublime to the ridiculous’ (and I’m being very careful not to say which is which), here’s a nice little story from Model Railroad Hobbyist.

Election campaign train dirty tricks

The story is told of a prankster in years past who was not a big
fan of Richard Nixon and who used to follow him around during
his political campaigns to pull disruptive practical jokes.

One day, Nixon was in the middle of a whistle-stop speach on
his campaign train when it suddenly pulled out of the station.
Apparently, the prankster had donned a rail worker’s cap and
signalled the engineer it was time to leave town …

One from a gentler time, perhaps?  However, I suspect it couldn’t happen now – health and safety would be on the politician’s side….


And to restore a little sanity, two topical UK railway links……

BBC program last night (now on iPlayer), ‘The trouble with our trains’.

And ‘ScotRail fined over train and station standards’.  I liked the bit that said that, “performance inspectors found areas which missed targets included station toilets, ticket machines, train seats, toilets and cleanliness.”  Not much else to go on, really…..

Posted in Inspiration, Out and about, Prototype, Weird and wonderful | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment