Avoid getting caught in the detail trap

Following on from the last post, an amusing little tale from Marty McGuirk….

Recently I attended a corporate retreat day where one of presentations that stuck in my head was titled “How to Measure Progress: Moving Forward Toward the Big Picture vs. Getting Caught up in the Details.” Quite a mouthful, but I immediately thought of model railroading. The instructor opened with a quote – not from a business tycoon or marketing giant, but an artist:

 “Nothing is less real than realism. Details are confusing. It is only by selection, by elimination, by emphasis, that we get at the real meaning of things.” ― Georgia O’Keeffe

This is often described as a golden age for model railroading. Never have we had it so good. We get detailed models, fresh out of the factory that reflect even the most minor differences between prototypes.

I’ll never forget when I was at Intermountain and we released the D&RGW version of the N scale SD40T-2. (Yes, some N scalers will recall the first run of the model had some teething pains, but that’s not the point of the story).   I’ll never forget the phone call I received a couple of weeks later from an irate (I mean really ticked off) modeler who sounded like he was about to have a coronary on the phone as he described the source of his angst:

“The jacking pads are the wrong shape on the SP tunnel motors. I’ve bought six of them, now I have to return them. And you <expletive deleted> SOB… now that you’ve ruined them no one will ever make them.”

“Excuse me,” I said, “the jacking pads?”

“Yes, the <f@#$ing> jacking pads. On the SP the tops are rounded – you <f@#%ers> did the Rio Grande ones and they’re squared off but you’re selling them as prototypical for the SP!!!”

This went on for what seemed like an eternity – I knew nothing was going to make this guy happy. At first I decided maybe he just needed to vent. After a while I almost started hoping for the aforementioned coronary to put him out of my, and what was clearly his, misery. For the record what he was referring to was the representation the metal stamping on the ends of the jacking pads located above the trucks of the sides of the jacking pads – the shape was less than 1/64” of inch. No one, and I mean not one person, ever commented on the shape of the jacking pads after that. But clearly it was important to him.

If that guy – who never mentioned his name – is reading this I’m sorry I ruined your enjoyment of the hobby. (And I almost mean that seriously.)

I bring this up to illustrate how we need to pick and choose which details we emphasize.  Models are, at their very essence, representations of a real object. Locomotives are big, heavy objects. Shape or form, color, and perhaps some use of light and shadow (“weathering”) to impact a sense of mass can be far more important to create the impression of a hard working piece of machinery than fretting over any individual minor detail.

In the context of a model railroad layout that entire locomotive is just another element. Just as a painting is made up of numerous brush strokes, the layout is comprised of numerous “micro details.” That locomotive, the track, and each car, structure and trees, are each “micro” details – that combine to create the “macro” item – a model railroad layout.

True artists have the ability to capture the essence of a subject in their chosen medium. And in some cases, less is more.

Posted in Inspiration, Jon's layout ramblings, Layout design | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Pundit Has His Notions And So Does Joe Average

Another gem from Mike Cougill’s OST Blog.  I wish I could express my thoughts as well as Mike does….

There are a lot of definitions imposed on model railroading. Look here and you’ll get one view. Look over there and you’ll find another. This pundit has his notions and so does Joe Average.

At the risk of merely adding to the noise, here’s a thought: model railroading is what you make of it.

If you approach it as a craft, then for you, it’s a craft. If you see it as art, then for you, it’s an art form. If all you see is a way to fill your space with cheap stuff, then all you’ll have is a basement full of cheap stuff.

I like to call it a craft instead of a hobby because that’s how I see and enjoy it. I also call it a craft because I respect and value what it brings to my life. For me it’s a way to learn and practice ideas like patience and self-discipline. I’m no longer modeling trains just to have model trains; I use my interest in the work as a way to work on myself. It’s therapy of a sort. It’s a way to relax and understand who I am. It’s a form of expression where I decide what values are important. This approach works for me and that’s all I can ask of it. If it didn’t add to my life in a positive way, then why bother?

I understand how different this is from the mainstream fun and good times playing train mind-set and I’m okay with that. The fun and good time crowd gets to do their thing and I get to practice my craft. As long as each one understands the choice they’ve made, then no harm, no foul.

It goes off the rails quickly when people insist that their ideas are the only ideas worth pursuing. That’s where tempers flare, egos get ruffled and that’s a shame because none of this is worth it. The Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius had a useful thought that applies here: “If the cucumber is bitter, then throw it out.” In other words, the solution is often quite simple: you don’t have to agree with or embrace every idea.

I’ve grown disillusioned with the generic hobby and the things it emphasizes. I no longer have any taste for big layouts, cheap hacks for everything and the relentless consumer hype. That’s just one man’s opinion though, as others find all of those things useful to their enjoyment of model trains.

Model railroading is not a homogenized pastime. It means different things to people and keeping that in mind will save a lot of wasted time worrying about the other guy. I can’t control what others like or dislike. I can only control my own actions and response. I can also choose the path that’s meaningful for me. We each decide whether the cucumber is bitter to the taste or not.

If all that’s a bit heavy for you, just go and run a train or hack some plastic or brass about!  But it again strikes a chord with me.  Looking at ESNG we have collectors, operators (or just train runners), and a few builders.  We all enjoy our hobby slightly differently, but manage to be polite to each other on club nights, and combine our skills when we go to a show.  Long may this continue!!

Posted in Inspiration, Jon's layout ramblings, Layout design | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

ESNG meeting – 7 December 2017

Christmas is coming, but 11 hardy souls decided that running trains was the perfect escape from the season….

Mind you, Rails of Sheffield’s Advent Calendar has come up with a few good bargains – my unrebuilt Merchant Navy had a running in turn.  The BR blue express livery only lasted from 1949-1953 or so, when blue gave way to green as BR found (rediscovering the wheel), that blue locomotives faded quickly.  But it’s a beautiful livery, and suited most of the large locos that received it.

Derek was testing a Farish 4-CEP – surely one of the least appreciated models around.  It beautifully captures the prototype – that was very much part of my upbringing.  I only travelled on them a few times, the 4-EPB being my usual method of transport, but they were always passing on the main line down to Orpington.

Allan’s East German locomotive and tankers seems to have Brexited through the Channel Tunnel – it was last seen running at Stuttgart.

And we had the usual Japanese and American contribution from Paul, Simon and Graham.  Also good to have Peter Swan visiting to see what we were up to.

We will be meeting on December 20th.  By that time we will definitely need to run a few trains!


Another modelling challenge – can you do this with your locos (actually it looks a bit like our track on club night….)


And a little bit of history from YouTube…..

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, Out and about | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The Carters fly east

Before Ian and Lily joined us in Stuttgart, they were in Hong Kong and Japan.  Here are a few of Ian’s holiday snaps….

This one is very familiar to me – a Hong Kong ‘tram jam’.  Still the best value ride in the world (except perhaps the HK Star Ferry.)

On to Japan.  If only the Rev Awdry could have anticipated this!  A tourist railcar at Kawaguchiko station near Fuji 5 lakes, a sort of Japanese version of Windermere!

Also at Kawaguchiko.  The liveries may appear a bit garish/unusual/silly but they work – they are generating tourist traffic on otherwise unlikely lines.

This is a view through the cab of the train from Nagoya to Takayama – a diesel multiple unit.

This is not a railway porcupine but a gauging car – the mechanical version of the lasers we use today!

Nagoya museum.  Don’t they use small buffers!


And a bonus modelling idea, courtesy of Storm Caroline, Scotrail and the BBC.  A railway track at Patterton was blocked by a trampoline ….

Posted in ESNG, Hong Kong, Japan, Out and about, Prototype | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

After the Goldrush

Looks like one of my favourite musicians is having a turn out.  From Reuters….

Singer Neil Young to auction model train collection

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) – Rock singer Neil Young is selling some of his most prized possessions – part of his model train collection.

A model train which is part of a collection of recording artist Neil Young’s most prized possessions being put up for auction by Julien’s Auctions in Los Angeles, California, U.S., December 9, 2017.

The Canadian folk-rock star is putting more than 230 of his vast collection of Lionel trains up for auction in Los Angeles in December, some with estimated selling prices of up to $9,000, Julien’s Auctions said on Thursday.

Young, 71, best known for his Woodstock-era songs as well as “Ohio” and “Heart of Gold,” has been a passionate model train enthusiast for more than 20 years.  His collection and vast layouts at his California ranch took off in the early 1990s as a means of connecting with his son Ben, who has cerebral palsy, Young said.   He also designed a remote control for trains that allows multiple trains to run at once, and a device that delivers realistic railroad audio to help his son get the most of out the hobby.

“It is just relaxing,” Young told David Letterman of his hobby in a 2012 appearance on Letterman’s television talk show.

Highlights of the Dec. 9 auction include the Lionel Hudson factory prototype locomotive with a pre-auction estimate of $4,000 to $9,000, and the H.O.A.R.D tour psychedelic Vanderbilt Hudson locomotive which is expected to sell for $3,000 to $6,000, Julien’s said.

Young is also selling some of his classic car collection.  They include a first in production 1953 Buick Roadmaster Skylark convertible 50th anniversary special edition, with a steering wheel hub saying “customized for Neil Young,” that has a pre-auction estimate of $200,000 to $300,000.

Young, who divorced his wife Pegi in 2014 after a 36-year marriage, said it was time for others to enjoy the items. A portion of the auction proceeds will benefit the Bridge School in California, which Pegi Young co-founded in 1986 for children with severe speech and physical impairments.

“Collecting all of these items has been my great joy. They have provided a source of inspiration, fun and creativity throughout my life,” Young said in a statement.  “Now it is time to share them with others in the world whom I hope will enjoy and love them as much as I have.”

Perhaps not something to emulate – dispose of the wife, then the model trains, then the classic cars!  Thanks to eldest daughter Ruth for knowing my musical tastes and drawing my attention to this! 

 

Posted in Inspiration, Out and about, Weird and wonderful | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Stuttgart 2017 #4 – Best of the rest

 

And finally a fly-over of Duncan’s Nm modules….

So that’s Stuttgart done and dusted for another year.  Allan and Derek had a good journey home, despite a wet drive through Germany, and we were unloading modules by 6pm on the Monday evening.  And 1150 or so miles were added to the clock on Allan’s truck.  Will we do it again next year?  Of course we will, all being well!

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Stuttgart 2017 #3 – Around the N-club modules

Today, a look at some of the N-club modules on show.  Some are there every year, but they are impressive pieces of work that are always worth a look.  I took most of these shots before the show opened, so they are mainly of scenery with few trains on view.

This station is one of my favourites.  It’s to scale size, with long platforms, and the buildings and figures create a very pleasing scene.

Here’s the American version.  Some strange modern buildings….

And back to Germany.  Another regular at Stuttgart, but it gets extended year by year.  It’s interesting to compare UK and European modelling.  We tend toward scratch building our structures, but in Europe full use is made of the many building kits available.  The knack is then to personalise and customise them into a realistic scene.  This has certainly been achieved in the layout below.  From the layouts that I have seen, perhaps the nearest to UK modelling is the Dutch.  They seem to have a more ‘English’ approach to layout design and scenery.  I often find the most interesting layouts are English built layouts of European or American prototypes.  I am obviously conditioned and biased by my own culture, but the combination of UK modelling ethos and overseas prototypes can make for an excellent model.

Another module, with the trains appearing between the buildings.

On shed….

And another bridge….

Is it a protest, a medieval procession, or just the regional equivalent of Morris men???

This engine depot puts ERIC to shame – it’s gigantic and the locos (even German 2-10-0’s) are dwarfed by the site.

Not sure whether the crane works….

The South African modules make a regular appearance, being stored at a nearby club, and make a pleasant change from European scenery.

Lastly today, Duncan takes to the air again, but over the ESNG modules…..

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Stuttgart 2017 #2 – Another day at the office

Thursday morning, and the show opened its doors.  Thursday was the quietest day, as some of the exhibitions in the adjoining halls didn’t start till the Friday.  The Messe has an admirable system, where one pays once to enter the 10 hall complex, then can visit all the exhibitions all day.

When measured up, the modular layouts added up to about 450m in length.  This didn’t include the stand-alone layouts, like West Sussex, but I think it did include the main N-club layout, the DCC layout, and the Nm layout.

And here’s Duncan’s panorama…

Another view of our empire, from the balcony.

We were fortunate in having good friends as our ‘neighbours’.  On one side of the junction was Olly, and his very detailed distribution depot and demolition site.

And on the other was Stefan’s lovely set of modules, that formed a sweeping curve, and made a change from the usual straight lines of the modules.  Lots of clean, detailed, modelling, including a farmyard with animal noises and swans swimming around a pond.  Stefan has been a good friend to ESNG, keeping us up-to-date with all that is going on, so it was good to ply him with mugs of tea, mince pies, and stilton cheese.

Thursday evening was time for the usual lock-in party, where all the exhibiting groups bring national dishes to share.  For the UK, it was Sussex Ale, cider, clotted cream and jam scones, cheese, mince pies and Walkers crisps.  Other European contributions were more exotic – I am told that the Dane’s curried raw herring is wonderful, but I can never face it!  There is also a significant potential to start the show on Friday morning with a nasty pale green tint to the face, if you have been drinking schnapps and vodka with the Danes and Finns.  I avoided this, but definitely ate too much cheese and dreamt  rather a lot….

Not to be missed is the Swiss raclette, a Swiss cheese that is melted on a special grill contraption (below) and scraped onto a slice of bread.  Delicious!

Duncan took a fly-by of the food (note the UK ale at the start!)

Finally, today, proof that the German sense of humour is as poor (or as good) as the British.  This was on a sign for one of the ladies toilets…..  I make absolutely no comment, in case it lowers my life expectancy.

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Stuttgart 2017 #1 – Getting there

Monday afternoon we loaded Allan’s pick-up with all the modules and support equipment for Stuttgart.  The most surprising thing was the number of legs needed, and the room taken by them all.  (Personal note – modify my modules to have integral fold-up legs in the boards.)

Tuesday, 3am (milkman time) Allan set off to pick up Derek, and head for the Channel Tunnel.  3pm they were in Stuttgart, and had offloaded everything in the hall in the neat pile seen below.  I followed Tuesday evening on Sleasyjet, and with a tailwind that got us in half-an-hour early on a 90 minutes flight, I was checked in by 8pm and rescuing my suitcase that had come out with Allan and Derek.

Wednesday morning, we were in the hall soon after 9am, and having unpacked the modules, were, as usual, waiting for our neighbours to get their layout constructed.

The hall looks very empty with no layout and no people – and it’s cold with the doors open.

Derek is already on the hunt for bargains…..

But by 11:30am we were ready to set things up.  The practice runs in the UK were very helpful, as we had everything in place and trains running soon after 3pm.  We went back to the hotel at 4 or so, to relax ready for the real work to start in the morning.

Our link to the outside world was this impressive junction, with full route selection and signalling.  I’m just glad that I didn’t have to operate it, as it was a bit complicated for bears of little brain.

This was the first time that we had exhibited mainly N-club modules, but we also included ERIC, and my N-mod loop, as it provided a length of 4-track line that was useful to store or overtake trains.  ERIC had the same selection of Southern Region locos as we took to the West Sussex show – it saved Derek from repacking them all….

The Clubhouse got its first run at Stuttgart….

Derek’s N-club corner was also there, with Aldersford.  We still had a few issues with the track on Aldersford, but a little adjustment, and removing a track pin and blob of solder improved things no end.  Overall, the layout ran very well, certainly as well as our neighbours’ layouts.

Nearby, Duncan had brought the traditional Sussex Ale, that also acted as a good shelf for the controllers for his Nm layouts.  Mark had said he wanted to operate the layout but it had to be near the beer – can’t get nearer than this….

The helix was there as ever.  It’s very impressive, but never quite delivers – the crashes after a breakaway decoupling are also impressive…..

Elsewhere, the West Sussex club were representing the N-gauge Society.  It was good to spend time with them again, having been to their show earlier in the month.  And very impressive, how they fit so many operators into such a small space….

Finally, proof that I was there.  One day I’ll get the hang of selfies – I think I need a selfie-stick (no way) or longer arms….

More next post….

Posted in ESNG, ESNG meetings, N Club International, Out and about | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Filling boxcars with stuffing

Last day today…..   Then packing up, and a flight home for me, and a long drive back to the UK for Allan and Derek.

 

But here’s a link to bemuse y’all….


No, Horace, I know Christmas is coming, but not that sort of stuffing…..

Not sure how much this topic has had devoted to this but it strikes me that the typical closed boxcar is a great resonance chamber, my thoughts are to simply put some sort of stuffing into space to “kill” the sound waves and potentially help quieten the unwanted noises. I’ve posted some images below of before and after.

Non scientifically they do seem to have a “denser” sound to them when  moving down track, but this may be a perception or wish rather than whats actually happening. Has anyone else looked into this or doing something similar?

This is a fascinating idea!  Probably more relevant for the larger scales, but I’ve never seen it done before.  It may still be helpful for metal models in ‘N’.

Follow the thread here.

Posted in Hints and tips, Weird and wonderful | Tagged , | Leave a comment